When it comes to concealed carry handguns, two names stand out in the market: the Smith & Wesson Shield Plus vs P365XL. Both are excellent choices, but which one is the best fit for your needs? In this comparison, we’ll break down their key features, performance, and why the Sig Sauer P365XL might be your ideal option.
Black Bayou Armory, a gun shop in Benton is a trusted name in the firearms industry, offering a wide selection of handguns, rifles, and accessories for enthusiasts and professionals alike. Whether you’re considering the Shield Plus or the P365XL, Black Bayou Armory provides expert guidance to help you make the right choice. Known for their commitment to quality and customer service, they offer competitive pricing and a seamless shopping experience for all your firearm needs.
Size & Ergonomics:
The P365XL offers a compact yet comfortable grip, making it an excellent option for better control. With its 12+1 capacity, the P365XL provides an edge over the Shield Plus, which comes with 10+1 or 13+1 magazine options.
Performance & Accuracy:
When comparing the P365XL vs Shield Plus, the P365XL is known for its flat-shooting design and X-Ray3 Day/Night Sights, which improve target acquisition in different lighting conditions. On the other hand, the Shield Plus features a crisp trigger and is a reliable performer, but its base model comes with white-dot sights.
If you prioritize fast follow-up shots, the P365XL stands out with its longer barrel and optics-ready slide.
Trigger & Controls:
Both pistols offer improved trigger designs compared to their predecessors. However, the P365XL provides a lighter, smoother trigger pull (~4.5–5 lbs), which contributes to better control and precision. The Shield Plus, while having a solid trigger, retains a slightly heavier pull (~6 lbs), which some shooters may prefer for added safety in concealed carry.
Capacity & Reloading:
The P365XL comes with a standard 12-round magazine, with options for 15-round extended magazines. The Shield Plus comes with either 10+1 or 13+1, making it competitive with higher capacity in its extended mag but lacking the P365XL’s modularity for aftermarket upgrades.
FAQs:
1. Is the P365XL snappy?
No, the P365XL is not very snappy. It has a longer grip and slide, which helps reduce recoil. Most people find it easy to control.
2. Is the Shield Plus snappy?
The Shield Plus has some recoil, but it is not too snappy. Its grip and weight help manage the kick, making it comfortable to shoot.
3. Is the Shield 2.0 the same as the Shield Plus?
No, they are different. The Shield Plus has a higher capacity and a better trigger than the Shield 2.0. But both are small, easy-to-carry guns.
4. Is the M&P Shield Plus a good gun?
Yes, the M&P Shield Plus is a good gun. It is reliable, accurate, and has a high-capacity magazine. Many people like it for concealed carry.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Smith & Wesson Shield Plus and the Sig Sauer P365XL are fantastic concealed carry options. If you prioritize optics-readiness out of the box, modularity (e.g., grip swaps), and compatibility with 15-round mags, the P365XL is a great option.
You can purchase the Sig Sauer P365XL online at Black Bayou Armory, a gun shop in Benton or buy it in-store by visiting our Gun Shop in Benton.
